Posts Tagged Azure Resource Manager
We get asked why do we use one over the other, I see a lot of discussions made around this topic. I can say there is no definitive answer, it all depends on your internal strategy and human capabilities.
So, I hear you say, are there capabilities that puts one ahead of the other?
Azure Resource Manager (ARM) vs. Terraform templates:
- ARM is a declarative language as in it submits the entire “goal state” to ARM for deployment – but doesn’t store a state of your infrastructure deployment like Terraform does
- ARM template syntax is specific to Azure – not portable – Resources can be deployed to AWS, GCP and Azure alike using Terraform
- Azure resources released in ARM template first – Terraform catches on later
- Terraform plan checks the deployment behaviour before it deploys and displays any changes before it actually happen – ARM can wipe out infrastructure as quickly as it can create them – what I want to say here – have change control in place to avoid this happening to you 🙂
- Some people find Terraform easier to read and digest especially if those templates are moved between developers – Terraform gives you the flexibility of adding comments while this isn’t available in ARM
- Both languages lets you embed custom scripts (i.e. in other languages such as Bash, Powershell etc.) in your templates which gives Terraform the advantage when a resource API provider is not yet available in Terraform
- Terraform runs pre-flight checks which means you can avoid failed deployments – ARM doesn’t warn you and your deployment might fail half way through deployment
This is my unbiased take on the matter … at the end of the day a clear business strategy should drive those concerns around deployment language and pattern. DevOps mindset has changed, people need to adapt as technologies change and evolve.